In the world of contemporary art, the rise of AI-generated works has sparked both fascination and controversy. As the owner of Formato Fine Arts, a gallery dedicated to showcasing unique, human-created masterpieces, I’ve had to carefully consider whether these digital creations align with our values and mission. After much reflection, I’ve decided that Formato Fine Arts will not feature AI-generated art, and here’s why.
The Essence of Human Creativity
Art has always been a deeply human endeavor. It’s a reflection of our experiences, emotions, and perspectives—a visual language that transcends words. When an artist creates a piece, they infuse it with their soul, their struggles, and their triumphs. This human element is what makes art so profoundly impactful.
AI-generated art, while technically impressive, lacks this human essence. It’s created by algorithms that mimic creativity but don’t truly understand it. The result is often visually stunning but devoid of the emotional depth and personal connection that define true artistry. At Formato Fine Arts, we believe that art should be a conversation between the artist and the viewer—a dialogue that’s rooted in shared human experience. AI-generated art simply cannot offer that.
Copyright and Ethical Concerns
Another significant issue with AI-generated art is the murky waters of copyright and ownership. Traditional artists have clear ownership of their work, with established legal frameworks protecting their intellectual property. However, with AI-generated art, the lines are blurred. Who owns the rights to a piece created by an algorithm? The programmer who wrote the code? The person who provided the prompts? Or does it belong to the public domain?
This ambiguity presents a serious risk, not just for artists but for galleries and collectors as well. Without clear copyright protections, the value and legitimacy of AI-generated art are questionable. At Formato Fine Arts, we prioritize the integrity and protection of the artists we represent. We want to ensure that every piece we showcase is not only original but also legally secure, with the artist retaining full rights to their work.
The Risk of Plagiarism
AI systems are trained on vast datasets of existing images, many of which are copyrighted works by living artists. This raises the troubling possibility that AI-generated art could inadvertently (or intentionally) replicate elements of existing works without proper attribution. Even subtle similarities could lead to accusations of plagiarism, undermining the credibility of the artwork and potentially leading to legal disputes.
As a gallery owner and an artist myself, I find this particularly concerning. Art should be a celebration of originality, not a blind rehashing of past works without consideration of their meaning and influence. By refusing to feature AI-generated art, Formato Fine Arts is taking a stand against the potential for creative theft and advocating for the protection of artistic integrity.
The Future of Art
While I recognize that AI will continue to play a role in the art world, I believe that its place is not in the galleries that celebrate human creativity. There’s a space for AI in design, in experimentation, and in pushing the boundaries of what’s possible—but at Formato Fine Arts, we remain committed to showcasing works that are born from the minds and hearts of human artists.
The future of art is one where technology and humanity coexist, but not where technology overshadows the human spirit. By upholding the values of originality, authenticity, and ethical integrity, Formato Fine Arts will continue to be a haven for those who appreciate art in its truest, most human form.
Join me in the celebration of art by browsing unique pieces from oil paintings over ceramics to metal sculptures by 40+ artists on Formatoart.com.
This article was first posted to the Formato Fine Arts LinkedIn page. Follow us there to read articles with a professional/business angle to the arts world before they get posted here.
Comments